Concept
The word arbitrage means making
a risk-less profit by entering into two or more transactions
of identical or equivalent instruments in two or more markets
at the same time. One who engages in this practice is called
an arbitrageur.
The simultaneous purchase and sale of something at different
prices sounds like a purely hypothetical transaction that
shouldn't ever exist. But various flavors of arbitrage or
near-arbitrage do exist, offering profits that are attractive
compared to the risk borne by the arbitrageur.
The arbitrageur buys
in the cash market and simultaneously sells in the futures
market getting a profit (Gross return). Arbitrage also exits
where the stock futures trading at discounts and the investor
previously held the underlying stock (Buy future and sell
stock in cash market). ). For calculation of net return, different
charges like brokerage, transaction cost, stamp duty, STT
(Securities Transaction Tax) etc should be deducted from the
gross return.
Overview
Before the NSE came into existence,
the price of the same stock varied across exchanges. Therefore,
it was easy to make money by buying at one exchange and selling
at a higher price on another. But nowadays, with real-time
transfer of information, the difference between the prices
of the same stock on different exchanges is minuscule. That’s
why people play more in derivatives and arbitrage between
the price differences in the cash and the futures markets.
In the Indian context arbitrage is largely concentrated in
stock futures; index arbitrage is not very popular as yet.
In the bull market,
investors are willing to pay a slight premium to the underlying
cash price in the futures market as they expect the stock
to rise in the short term and are willing to pay the premium
(discounts do also happen at times of dividend and bearishness
in the stocks).
Market
Makers: True Arbitrage
Arbitrage is being done mostly
by market makers because when the difference do appear, the
window of opportunity lasts for only a short time (i.e. seconds
or minutes). That’s why they tend to be executed primarily
by market makers who can spot these rare opportunities quickly
and do the transaction in seconds.
Market makers have
several advantages over retail traders:
• Far more trading capital
• Generally more skill
• Up-to-the-second news
• Faster computers
• More complex software
• Access to the dealing desk
• And more
Combined, these factors
make it nearly impossible for a retail trader to take advantage
of pure arbitrage opportunities. Market makers use complex
software that is run on top-of-the-line computers to locate
such opportunities constantly. Once found, the differential
is typically negligible, and requires a vast amount of capital
in order to profit. The retail traders would likely get burned
by commission costs. Needless to say, it is almost impossible
for retail traders to compete in the risk-free genre of arbitrage.
|